
Hey there.
One of the questions I get more than almost any other is some version of this: how do I know what to offer?
And it’s a fair question. But I want to reframe it slightly. The real question isn’t “what should I offer?” The real question is: what is my maximum purchase price?
Because that’s the number that runs the whole deal. Everything else — what you offer, what you negotiate, whether you walk away — flows from that one number.
Here’s how to get there, and why the details matter more than most investors realize.
Start With the Right Comps
Before you can calculate your maximum purchase price, you need an after repair value. And to get a reliable ARV, you need reliable comps.
Here’s where most newer investors go wrong: they go too far out.
If you can find comps within a mile and a half, use those. If you can find them within a mile, even better. The closer your comp is to your subject property, the more it reflects the actual market for that specific property in that specific neighborhood.
Going out to five or eight miles to find comps might give you more data points, but it comes with a price: you’ve just increased your risk. A comp that’s eight miles away may be in a completely different neighborhood, with different schools, different amenities, different buyer demand. Using it as the basis for your offer is a guess at best.
If you can’t find solid comps close by, that’s information too. It tells you something about how unique that property or area is — and that’s worth knowing before you commit to a price.
When You Have a Range, Use the High End — If the House Will Be Fully Rehabbed
Say you’ve got three comps within a mile and a half and they’re giving you an ARV range of $620,000 to $695,000. That’s a $75,000 spread.
Where in that range should your ARV sit?
If the house is going to be fully rehabbed before it’s sold — new kitchen, new bathrooms, new flooring, new roof, new windows — here’s something most investors don’t factor in: a freshly rehabbed house commands a premium over a comparable house in average used condition.
Why? Because of what I’d call useful life.
Think about the roof. A thirty-year roof on a used house might have ten years left on it. It’s not leaking, it looks okay, but it’s got limited remaining life. That’s factored into what a buyer will pay.
That same house, fully rehabbed, now has a brand new roof. Thirty years of remaining useful life. A hundred percent of that value is part of the package a buyer is purchasing.
Apply that across everything that gets replaced — the roof, the HVAC, the kitchen, the flooring — and you’ve got a property whose total useful life value is significantly higher than a comparable house in average used condition.
Based on conversations I’ve had with appraisers over the years, that premium can be as much as 10 percent. In our example, 10 percent of $620,000 is $62,000. That puts you right at the top end of the range, around $682,000.
So: when you’re wholesaling a house that will end up fully rehabbed, don’t default to the low end of your comp range. The high end is defensible. Use it.
Run the Formula
Now that you have your ARV, the calculation is straightforward.
Maximum Purchase Price = ARV × 0.65 − Estimated Repairs
That’s it. This formula builds in the spread that lets you sell the house to a rehabber at a price that works for them, while still leaving you a wholesale fee.
If your ARV is $682,000 and you estimate repairs at $80,000:
$682,000 × 0.65 = $443,300
$443,300 − $80,000 = $363,300 maximum purchase price
That’s the most you can pay for that property and still have a deal that works.
The Word “Maximum” Is Not Optional
Here’s where discipline comes in. And I’m going to be direct about this.
The number one reason investors get stuck with a property they can’t sell is not bad luck. It’s not a slow market. It’s not some unpredictable thing. It’s that they paid too much.
The word “maximum” in maximum purchase price means exactly what it says. It is the ceiling. Not a guideline. Not a starting point for negotiation with yourself. The ceiling.
What happens when you’re at an auction or in a negotiation and the price creeps up toward your number? Your brain starts talking.
Well, I might have been conservative on the ARV. I could probably push it. The repairs — I probably over-estimated those a little. And then, the number creeps past the ceiling, and you let it.
Don’t.
Calculate it once, write it down if you have to, and treat it as immovable. When you’ve hit your maximum purchase price, you stop. You walk away. That discipline is what separates investors who do this consistently from investors who have one good experience and two bad ones.
If the Deal Doesn’t Work at Your Number, the Deal Doesn’t Work
This is a hard thing to accept, but it’s freeing once you do.
Sometimes the seller wants more than you can pay. Sometimes the numbers just don’t work. That’s okay. That’s not a failure — that’s a decision.
A realistic seller — one who’s listed at a price well below ARV because they know the house needs work — is worth your time. An unrealistic seller who’s asking close to full ARV on a house that needs a complete rehab is not.
The formula helps you tell the difference fast. When you know your maximum purchase price before you walk into a negotiation, you stop wasting time on deals that were never going to work.
Find the Motivated Sellers First
All of this starts with finding the right properties in the right situations. You’re not going to find these on the MLS. You find them by targeting homeowners who have a compelling reason to sell — pre-foreclosures, absentee owners, vacant properties, stacked motivations.
The Real Estate Data Feed is where our investors pull that data. It gives you motivated seller leads across the country, filtered by the conditions that matter — updated regularly and searchable by market. There’s a 7-day free trial if you want to see what’s available where you’re focused.
Know your number. Work your formula. And go find the deals worth making.
Maximum Purchase Price = ARV × 0.65 − Estimated Repairs. In the example in the post, an ARV of $682,000 and estimated repairs of $80,000 give a maximum purchase price of $363,300.
Use comps within a mile and a half if you can, and within a mile if possible. Going out to five or eight miles may give you more data points, but it increases your risk because a comp that far away may be in a completely different neighborhood, with different schools, amenities, and buyer demand.
A freshly rehabbed house commands a premium over a comparable house in average used condition because of useful life — for example, a new roof has thirty years of remaining useful life. Based on conversations with appraisers, that premium can be as much as 10 percent. In the example, 10 percent of $620,000 is $62,000, which puts the ARV at the top of a $620,000 to $695,000 range, around $682,000.
Regards.
Cameron Dunlap
** Maximum Purchase Price = ARV × 0.65 − Estimated Repairs **
Is this new above? Why was the 70% rule change?
Hi Ray. This is not new. 70% is what your buyer will typically want to pay.